Showing posts with label Muslim Brotherhood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Muslim Brotherhood. Show all posts

Monday, August 26, 2013

The future of the Sunni Muslim Soul, part I

Thomas Friedman had hi usually provocative op-d article in last Sunday's Times:

The New York Times, http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/21/opinion/Friedman-close-to-the-edge.html?hp&pagewanted=print

The article is worth reading in full.  Here are some quotations from the article I want to emphases.  My comments are in italics and blue.

In short, I see in Egypt and especially in Syria a battle for those Sunni soul: those Sunni in Turkey and elsewhere who are willing to accept democracy; and those in Saudi Arabia and theEmirates who prefer a secular dictatorship to any Sunni acceptance of any form of democracy.  We'll see how it plays out.
What’s especially depressing is that the leadership and options needed to reverse these trends don’t seem to be on offer. Egyptians today are being given a choice between a military that seems to want to take Egypt back to 1952, when the army first seized power (I think the Saud dictators an those in Dubai prefer either of Friedman's choices.   Eighteen Billion from the Saudi and Dubai (Dick Cheney's preferred tax haven) speaks with a loud voice).— and kept those Muslim Brothers in their place — and the Muslim Brothers, who want to go back to 622, to the birth of Islam and to a narrow, anti-pluralistic, anti-women, Shariah-dominated society — as if that is the answer to Egypt’s ills.
“Egypt’s striking lesson today is that its two most powerful, organized and trusted groups — the Muslim Brotherhood and the armed forces — both proved to be incompetent in the business of governance,”(The US press asserts Brotherhood incompetence as if its truth is self-evident; always without any suggestion of proof.  Did the Saudi and military fore-ordain failure?  Did they help it along?  I don't know; I am unwilling to accept the incompetence assertion on faith.) the political scientist Rami Khouri wrote in The Beirut Daily Star last week.
The lack of other organized and credible indigenous groups of citizens that can engage in the political process and shape new constitutional systems is largely a consequence of how military officers, members of tribes, and religious zealots have dominated Arab public life for decades.

 Images  from Cairo this past week fro rt, a Russian national publication:  Russian point of view; perhaps not always typical but always the most dramatic images.  Don't know the Russian point of view on Egypt's troubles.










Areas of Egypt affected by the curfew.  
Rocket from the Sinai are reported to have landed i Israel.































Thursday, November 15, 2012

Israel's Home-made Existential Crisis

Israel and the Palestinians are trading explosions, killing each other, and Israel is threatening another invasion of the Gaza Strip.

Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi and cabinet members are visiting Gaza as a show of solidarity, and has recalled his ambassador to Israel.  See the Washington Post article after the jump.

Israel's misguided leaders are renewing threats to Bomb Iran unilaterally, misguided because doing so will not stop Iran from Getting the Bomb [see Council on Foreign Relations,
 Oxford Research Group: 
Iran: Consequences of a War] and will cast Israel out of the Family of Nations.

Egypt's Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa recently issued a a fatwa declaring Shia (Iran) and Sunni (Arab) versions of  the Quran compatible, ending 1,600 year of animosity between the two, so far as Egypt is concerned.

Th Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood is siding more decidedly with the Muslim Palestinians.

Russia has Islamist radicals in its southern Republics who have done Russia much more harm than they ever have done to the US.  Russia can use help from Iran and from Egypt and can offer plenty of help in return.

Israel has more than a million Palestinians living as second-class persons under its control.  Israel cannot continue as it is and remain a democratic nation.

In short:

Make Peace between Israel and a Palestinian State.

Dom't Bomb Iran.

Images of potential brotherhood between Israel and Palestine follow.











Make football, not war!